Northern Liberties residents say windshield barnacles are predatory, question legality

PHILADELPHIA (WPVI) — A controversial parking enforcement tactic in the Northern Liberties section of Philadelphia is drawing complaints from drivers who say they are being charged $100 or more to remove devices called “barnacles” from their windshields.

Barnacles, which attach to a car’s windshield, are being used in a private lot at 4th and Spring Garden streets in the city.

SEE ALSO | Business owners, officials debate legality of barnacle parking device as complaints grow

Lawyers for the parking company say the devices are intended to keep spaces open for plaza customers. But according to discussions by the city’s public safety committee, barnacles are largely unregulated and do not fall under existing towing laws.

Nick Villalta said he parked in the lot recently to run across the street to CVS.

“Literally not even five minutes later, I notice the barnacle on my windshield,” Villalta said. He paid $100 to have it removed. “Some poor lady in a Tesla pulls up. They literally take it off my car and put it right on hers,” he said.

Some residents believe the practice is predatory and illegal.

“This is a private parking lot. I get that there is a right way and a wrong way, but booting a car and trying to extort people for money is the wrong way to go about this,” said Jerry Erlich of Northern Liberties.

“Right now, I don’t believe they are legal, but we’re waiting for our legal department to verify that. And we’re hoping to have legislation in place in the new year,” said Councilmember Mark Squilla on Wednesday.

RELATED: Company behind controversial windshield barnacles making changes | Action News Investigation

When contacted on Tuesday, Mikina Harrison, founder & CEO of Bob’s Sponges Parking Enforcement Services, referred questions to her attorney.

The lot is owned by “The Robinson Group,” which uses the company for parking enforcement, according to attorney Kevin Mincey.

“As far as I know, as I read the law and our understanding of it is, that the use of a barnacle is not illegal, and so we’ve reached out to the city to try to get clarification on that issue, and we’re waiting for a response,” he added.

6abc first reported on this issue in 2023. Critics say companies using barnacles are skirting the city’s Ticket-to-Tow law.

Erlich said, “The right way is to call the police and have them ticket the car and then it can also be towed.”

Mincey believes people are exploiting that knowledge and taking chances, hoping to be in and out before police or the PPA can arrive and also ignoring posted signage.

“They’re rolling the dice, and sometimes people get away with it. In this instance, people are not getting away with it,” he said. “We’ve all done that, but it doesn’t mean that it’s right, and it doesn’t mean the people who own these private lots don’t have rights.”

The city discussed regulating or banning barnacles in late 2023. Councilmember Curtis Jones, who introduced this legislation, says he called for a meeting this Friday with all parties. He hopes to finalize the ordinance as soon as possible.

“It’s upsetting that the city hasn’t acted sooner,” Erlich said.

Philadelphia Police released the following statement regarding the matter:

“Towing companies are not authorized to immobilize vehicles using devices and then request that officers issue citations solely for the purpose of facilitating a tow. If there is a parking violation, an officer should be contacted so a citation can be issued when appropriate, after which the towing process may proceed in accordance with applicable regulations. Parking lot attendants or tow operators are not permitted to detain or hold a vehicle by using immobilization devices as a means of compelling payment or cooperation.”

Mincey maintains the barnacle is not illegal.