
A scarecrow representing a Muslim woman wearing a hijab who becomes a U.S. citizen has won an annual contest in Connecticut, despite social media backlash that led to an outpouring of community support in response.
The scarecrow, named Fatima, was created by Manchester Adult and Continuing Education for the town’s annual scarecrow contest ahead of Halloween. Wearing a hijab and clothing representing Muslim cultural heritage, Fatima was designed to celebrate immigrants who become U.S. citizens and highlight the school’s citizenship classes.
For Manchester resident Ikram Hales, who wears a hijab herself, seeing the scarecrow was an unexpected and emotional experience.
“It brought a lot of emotions and joy mostly. We did take a photo of it,” Hales said. “I’m really happy to see a reflection of me somewhere where I least expected it to be.”
The scarecrow’s clothing belonged to a school staff member and was intended to represent her cultural heritage.
Dr. Diane Clare-Kearney, director of Manchester Adult and Continuing Education, said Fatima symbolizes the opportunities available to immigrants seeking citizenship.
“She represents opportunity and welcome. The idea of ‘If I can do it, you can do it’,” she said.
While the scarecrow initially received a warm reception, it also sparked criticism on social media over its placement in front of the Army-Navy Club.
One Facebook commenter described the scarecrow as a “slap in the face” to veterans and a “universal symbol of terrorism”.
Clare-Kearney said the comments were upsetting.
“It was discouraging. It was dismissive. It was hurtful,” she said.
However, the backlash also prompted an outpouring of support from Manchester residents, with members of the local Muslim community pushing back on the negative comments.
Manchester Mayor Jay Moran addressed the controversy during a November Board of Directors meeting, condemning the negative comments and apologizing to those who were hurt.
“My Muslim friends have become some of my close friends. Close friends. I’ve spent high holy days with you, and I apologize for the hurt you received from the comments,” he said.
Hales said the community’s response was meaningful.
“It was really heartwarming. It’s just a different level of care, and that’s what makes a community, a community,” she said.
Other Muslim residents said the controversy could serve as an opportunity for greater understanding.
“If they get to know us, then that thing is going to change because Manchester is very diverse,” resident Khairul Alam said. “We want that, and Fatima is going to keep on winning.”
Despite the criticism, Fatima ultimately won the town’s scarecrow contest, a result that Hales said reinforced her sense of belonging in Manchester.
“I’m like, yeah! This is our community, so it was very special, and I felt like I had a place,” she said.
Manchester Adult and Continuing Education said that with Fatima’s victory, the school will consider returning to enter the scarecrow contest again.