‘I wish they didn’t work’: How $127 million in negative ads landed in Maine’s U.S. Senate race

 

Rotten. Irritating. Disgusting. 

That’s how several Maine voters described the onslaught of negative advertising in this year’s election when leaving the polls. The disgust isn’t likely to dissipate when Mainers learn how much money was spent on negative ads during the state’s record-breaking U.S. Senate race. 

Republicans and Democrats spent more than $127 million attacking each other in the race, according to a Maine Monitor review of data from the ad-tracking firm AdImpact. 

Most of that spending came from outside groups, largely allowing the candidates and their campaigns to project more positive and policy-focused messages on the airwaves, while their allies traded blistering and factually dubious attacks. Those dueling salvos against Republican incumbent Susan Collins and Democratic challenger Troy Jackson featured a level of animosity that voters, political observers, campaign operatives and candidates alike found unprecedented in Maine elections. 

“The whole election has been pathetic because of the way the candidates all attacked each other,” said independent voter Bonnie O’Reilly outside of the polls in Casco on Election Day. “It’s been a rotten campaign, and I’m embarrassed. I’m ashamed to be American.”

Elections across the U.S. saw a record level of ad spending this year, according to a recent report from AdImpact. More than $12 billion poured into this midterm cycle, exceeding the $11.2 billion spent on the 2024 presidential election. This is the first time that a midterm has seen more spending than a presidential election. 

In Maine, the Senate race saw more than $289 million in spending, smashing the 2020 record of more than $200 million. With Maine’s relatively small population, it also made the Collins-Jackson matchup the most expensive race per voter across the country. 

 

Notably, the party that spent the most on negative ads did not win. 

Republican-aligned groups launched more than $74 million in negative ads against Democrats in the race, compared with nearly $53 million from Democrats attacking Collins. Of the total negative spending, Republicans accounted for 58.4 percent compared to 41.6 percent for Democrats. That largely tracks with the overall spending breakdown in the race, both negative and positive, with Republicans responsible for 60 percent and Democrats 40 percent. In total, Democrats ran 60 unique negative ads attacking a member of the other party and Republicans ran 57. 

While all of the cross-party negative ads from Democrats targeted Collins, who went unchallenged in the Republican primary, the contested and unprecedented nature of Maine Democrats’ primary process this cycle meant that the Republican attack ads were spread out among several different candidates. 

Republicans spent more than $64 million on ads attacking Jackson in a condensed period of just over three months after he became the replacement nominee in late July. Republicans had already spent nearly $10 million attacking previous Democratic nominee Graham Platner and less than $50,000 against former primary candidate Gov. Janet Mills. Even when solely comparing the attacks against Jackson and Collins, Republican negative ads accounted for nearly 55 percent of the total. (The Mills campaign spent more than $500,000 on two ads attacking Platner in the primary, which The Monitor did not include in its analysis.)

It appears that this is not the first time in a contentious U.S. Senate race in Maine where the party that spent more on negative ads went on to lose. While The Monitor does not have access to 2020 spending data from AdImpact, a report from the campaign finance reform group American Promise provides some insight into the negative spending in that race. 

A Democratic-aligned super PAC called the Senate Majority PAC spent $27.9 million, more than double the $12.6 million spent by the Republican-aligned Senate Leadership Fund. More than 98 percent of that ad spending was negative, according to American Promise. 

Democrat Sara Gideon still lost to Collins six years ago. And in this year’s race, the Republican edge in both overall and negative ad spending was not enough to save Collins in her re-election bid.

‘Money and meanness’

Collins had won five straight campaigns dating back to the mid-1990s, and she had never seen anything like the level of negative personal attacks in Maine this cycle. 

“This campaign has been unique in Maine’s history, in the number of personal attacks,” Collins said during the campaign, as reported by WMTW. “I’ve been accused of all sorts of things.” 

Those accusations included that she has been “getting rich from stock trading,” as was claimed in an attack ad that Democratic group WinSenate spent more than $4 million to air. WinSenate also spent more than $3 million on a pair of different ads accusing Collins of accepting campaign donations in a pay-to-play scheme with a defense contractor and of rewriting federal contracting rules to benefit her husband’s company. 

The Collins campaign repeatedly refuted corruption and character attacks against her, including by calling the pay-to-play allegations false and noting that the stock portfolio belongs to her husband, Tom Daffron, and is managed by a third party. 

And while Collins faced millions in attack ads alleging corruption or self-dealing, it was Jackson who bore the brunt of that type of ad.

 

Democrats spent more than $13 million on negative ads against Collins focused on character, corruption, special interests, her career as a politician and stock trading, according to AdImpact data. That total was dwarfed by the more than $37 million that Republicans spent against Jackson on issues such as character, corruption, special interests and lobbying.

Republican attack ads frequently accused Jackson and his family of self-dealing, including by highlighting his son Chace Jackson’s role as a lobbyist in Augusta while Troy Jackson was the Maine Senate president. Unlike in Congress, Maine ethics laws do not prevent immediate family members from lobbying their lawmaker relatives. As with Collins, Jackson and his campaign repeatedly refuted the attacks against him. 

“I think they were throwing so many negatives at us that perhaps it became unbelievable that all these things could be true,” said David Farmer, a longtime Maine political strategist who served as a senior advisor on the Jackson campaign. Farmer emphasized that he was speaking to The Monitor in his personal capacity and not on behalf of the campaign. 

Corruption was a common theme in negative ads across the country. Nationally, it was one of the five biggest issues that Democrats shifted toward after the primary. 

Not all of Maine’s corruption-themed ads seem to have landed the same way with voters. 

“Corruption is a big, vague word. So there’s a number of different ways to tell that story, and some ways voters might find distasteful,” said University of Southern Maine political science professor Ron Schmidt. “It’s possible that, ‘Was there a pay-for-play situation involved with this office’ is different from, ‘There’s something creepy about that guy’s family.’” 

Republicans leaned into family attacks against Jackson — not just by highlighting his son’s lobbying, but by repeatedly emphasizing reports that Jackson’s longtime partner and mother of his children, Lana Pelletier, is also his second cousin. 

All of these factors made for a cycle of negative spending such that candidates and operatives had not seen in Maine before. 

“It was a combination of money and meanness this cycle that was different,” Farmer said. 

Negative ads work, but there can be backlash 

Farmer also worked as part of Democrats’ outside spending effort in the 2020 race and said negative ads can be an effective tool — even if people say they don’t like them.

“The reason that folks run attack ads, for good or ill, is because voters react to them as they’re intended to,” said Farmer, whose experience with Maine elections dates back to 2002 when he first moved to the state as a journalist.

But he didn’t see the negative ad spending as the determinative reason for each party’s loss in 2020 and 2026. He thought this year’s result was better explained by a troubled economy, high prices, inflation, the unpopularity of the Iran War and pushback against U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement activity. 

“Those dynamics, those factors, were much more important than the comparative ad spend,” he said.

Still, Farmer recognized how unpopular this type of campaign advertising can be among the Maine electorate. And he doesn’t like it either. 

“I believe that if you ask Maine voters, 99 out of 100 would say that they hate the negative ads and that they don’t work on them,” Farmer said. “But that doesn’t mean they don’t help drive the conversation during a campaign.”

The attacks were successful in pushing down both candidates’ favorability numbers, he said, and the candidates frequently had to respond to them on the campaign trail.

“I do think that there’s declining efficacy on spending, particularly on advertising,” Farmer said. “But where that point is, is more art than science.”

Colby College government professor Nicholas Jacobs found the sheer amount of negative ads to be both unusual and interesting, noting that “it is hard to imagine that they have any real added marginal value beyond a certain point.”

Travis Trawick, the CEO of voter outreach company FullPAC, which provides opposition research and political texting services to campaigns across the political spectrum, shared similar input about the ad volume.

“Negative ads do work, but they stop working after a certain point,” he said. “There’s a saturation point where after a few exposures to these things, it’s not changing people’s minds — and even it’s causing some resentment.”

That saturation can be especially pronounced in a small state like Maine, Trawick and others said, in part because air time is often cheaper than in larger markets. 

“Campaigns try to book as much advertising time as they can as early as they can nowadays,” Schmidt said. “The results of that can definitely be voters just becoming completely disgusted with the candidates, long before the election actually takes place, because it’s just so much.”

Schmidt also highlighted the incentives for campaigns to go negative. 

“Voters remember negative ads longer than they remember positive ads,” Schmidt said. “Negative ads, if they figure out a way to do it, can play on emotions in a way that’s very useful for a campaign.”

Trawick thinks that, in some cases, candidates wish that outside groups trying to boost them wouldn’t go so negative. While some negative ads can have the desired effect, he said that’s not always the case, especially in a small media market. 

“They can absolutely backfire,” said Trawick, whose company had clients in 46 different states this cycle including in some down-ballot races in Maine. 

Jacobs highlighted one ad that may have backfired on the Collins campaign this year: a spot featuring legendary Maine broadcaster Bill Green that drew scrutiny for its critique of Jackson. 

In that ad, technically considered a contrast ad by AdImpact and thus not included in the negative ad totals, Green said that Jackson “doesn’t have the tools he needs to be effective” in the Senate, and said “we’re not talking about buying a cord of wood here.” 

That line was an apparent reference to Jackson’s work years ago as a logger, and Democrats seized on it by framing the ad as out of touch with working Mainers. 

“The one thing I think we can say, anecdotally, is that negative ads — when done poorly — can act as a sort of rallying cry for the other side,” Jacobs said. 

What makes Maine different 

Not only is Maine a small market compared with other states, but it also has one of the most engaged electorates in the country. That level of engagement, along with a large independent voting block that has often rewarded moderation and collegiality from its politicians, could have also factored into the response to negative ads here.

“There’s always a danger to backlash from negative ads, but Maine’s reaction is different from the reaction in a lot of other areas in the U.S. in a way that’s really interesting,” Schmidt said.

In many places, backlash to negative ads can drive down participation rates, Schmidt explained. But that didn’t happen in Maine. The state saw record midterm turnout this election, and its more than 60 percent turnout rate is among the highest in the country. 

“Mainers show up to vote like nowhere else in the country,” Schmidt said. “So I think here we might have an example of a backlash that has a negative effect on the people who are trying to run the negative campaign.”

Maine has often featured a more collegial political discourse relative to other places, which could fuel some pushback against negative advertising. 

“If you create a discrepancy between how your electorate likes to think of itself and what the local politics are like, people can react against you and your campaign,” Schmidt said about this year’s race. “That may be part of what happened.”

Maine’s high level of political engagement might help voters better distinguish fact from fiction in negative ads, Farmer said, but ultimately those ads still affect voter behavior. 

“I wish they didn’t work, and that it was more a fight about worldview and values and accountability for votes and actions than some of the things we see,” Farmer said. “But that doesn’t mean that they don’t work. They still work. And that’s why we saw so much money spent on them.”

 

Rose Lundy contributed reporting on Election Day.

Connect

css.php