
Here’s a challenge for Republicans who haven’t been on NPR lately: Take a call from NPR. Answer questions there.
Some Republicans in power don’t talk with NPR, assuming the network is against them. Other Republicans have told me they appreciate NPR, but assume they have nothing to gain from talking to NPR’s audience. It’s a polarized world. Plenty of partisan media will broadcast their messages to their core voters.
This matters because one job of independent media is to find out what the government is doing and why. We have many sources of information, and will use them whether officials talk or not, but it helps the public when officials are open with the citizens who employ them.
Over the past two years, Democrats who were out of power have taken a different approach to media that they see as not on their team. Quite a few have done high-profile interviews on Fox News, answering whatever questions they’re asked.
Democrats realized the electorate is shifting—less stable than it seemed. They engaged with that electorate wherever they could find it. And it happens that they just won a bunch of red states in the midterm elections.
Maybe there’s some value to reaching beyond your comfort zone.
It would be wrong to think that no Republicans turned up on NPR over the first two years of President Trump’s second term. Many Republicans and conservatives have given us time, ranging from Steve Bannon to Doug Wilson to Tucker Carlson to Mike Waltz to Ted Cruz to Jim Jordan to Spencer Cox. We’ve heard conservative influencers such as Brett Cooper and writers like Yuval Levin and Jonah Goldberg and John Ullyot. We’ve heard conservatives who support President Trump, others who oppose him, and still others who have unrelated matters to discuss. We’ve included them in the mix with democratic socialists and “radical centrists” and many people besides.
But in the past two years, many figures in the Trump administration, in Congress, and in Trump-aligned parts of the tech world have not accepted NPR’s invitations. The president explicitly targeted NPR for its coverage—ordering Congress to cut funding to local public stations—and many Republicans would not like to cross him. It’s gone a little beyond the normal friction involved in reaching public officials from any administration. In some cases we’ve even had trouble connecting with Republicans who came on NPR in the past, who once took our call or explained their view of government or explained their legislative priorities or pushed for a presidential candidate or ran for president.
Some readers may feel they know exactly why Republicans in power declined to appear: “media bias.” Why “legitimize” a perceived enemy? Republicans made a target of NPR during the 2024 presidential campaign, seizing on a famous essay by a former NPR editor.
The accusations of bias back then were mostly bogus, and you can find receipts here. NPR’s coverage is independent, and while we do make mistakes, we’re always back to try again the next day. But you need not agree with me about that. If Republicans believe NPR is hostile, it only strengthens the case for them to engage. Political figures benefit when they take skeptical questions from citizens. That’s the American way. Some Republicans haven’t done it, and that may have been a factor in their recent election debacle.
Some Democrats who won the elections took a different approach, accepting invitations to appear on Fox News.
Just this week, as Maryland Sen. Chris Van Hollen launched his challenge to Chuck Schumer for Senate leadership, he did interviews on MSNOW, ABC, NPR, and CNN—and Fox. He took the Democratic leadership struggle to the network at the heart of the Republican party.
“Democrats need to take their case to every single American,” Van Hollen explained to me. In 2026, Democrats won elections in traditionally red states. In 2028, he said, they have an opportunity to extend that streak. “Nobody should be scared about going on Fox to talk to the American people, and I think that’s a very important message for us to send if we want to win back people’s trust.”
On Tuesday, as I was writing this essay, my colleague Luke Garrett got my attention: There was Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez on Fox News.
She’s hardly alone. Pete Buttigieg was an early leader in making his party’s case on Fox. During the 2026 campaign, Abdul El-Sayed took questions on Fox News in August, and again in October. James Talarico of Texas took questions on Fox News in September.
It got to the point where the president complained that Fox News was giving too much time to Democrats and independents!
Judging by my conversations with voters, this was smart. Many right-leaning voters were disillusioned. Democrats showed up to make their case to those voters.
It’s true that on conservative media, Democrats faced questions they might prefer to avoid. Talarico was asked about transgender issues, for example. But this meant conservative voters heard Talarico for themselves. They didn’t only hear about Talarico from Republicans who played up transgender issues and even suggested Talarico was trans.
Do Democrats suddenly feel Fox is “fair and balanced”? Of course they don’t. But by engaging with the right, Democrats reach voters who may not feel entirely comfortable in either the blue or red camp. A lot of people aren’t.
Democrats also get a chance to sharpen their own arguments against criticism they may consider uncomfortable or unfair.
It used to be that the roles were reversed. Progressives were described as “snowflakes” while conservatives demanded free speech. Just two years ago, Democrats did not manage to appear on a popular podcast that was considered hostile to them, while Republicans seized opportunities on mainstream media—the same outlets they accused of bias all the time. You can make a case that the Democratic approach was self-defeating, while the Republican approach helped them swim against the tide.
The political left had a tendency to shut down opposing views, and to question or even demand apologies from anyone who talked with the other side. Democrats were derided as isolated, off base, out of touch—pushing policies and ideas that did not resonate beyond people like themselves.
During that distant era of just-two-years-ago, the Democrat in the White House did not take questions from NPR, except in press conferences. President Biden never did an interview with NPR during his term. Biden, of course, faced doubts about serving at his age. Finally Biden did a debate, and, among other things, he seemed out of practice with tough questions.
Now Democrats are talking, and it’s often Republicans who have been isolating themselves, helped by the power of the state, which has repeatedly threatened or blocked access to independent media. At some point the government is not just shaping the news environment but also degrading the information available to themselves.
At least the president has taken questions from the White House press corps. But he has often used the occasion to attack the questioner instead of answering.
Which side seemed out of touch by November 2026? This week on NPR we’ll broadcast an interview with the conservative podcaster Ben Shapiro. His post-election podcast took note of President Trump’s final campaign appearance, which focused on his renovation of the reflecting pool in Washington. Shapiro’s comment: “Why? Just why?”
In an election post-mortem, Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis suggested that the whole conservative media ecosystem was out of touch: “I think we need a big change in kind of the conservative media culture. Because a lot of that is a grift, and it’s pay-to-play, and it’s just not offering very much in the way of strong ideas and things that are really going to illuminate your understanding.”
I understand DeSantis to be saying that a lot of Republicans closed themselves off from reality, making harder for them to govern and to win.
Maybe more of them should turn on NPR.
Republican leaders have an opportunity to compete in front of all audiences, just the way that they used to do, and in the way that Democrats have begun to do. In the wake of their election defeat, they might do well to return a few more calls.